Open-Source Vs. Commercial Software: A False Dilemma - InformationWeek

InformationWeek is part of the Informa Tech Division of Informa PLC

This site is operated by a business or businesses owned by Informa PLC and all copyright resides with them.Informa PLC's registered office is 5 Howick Place, London SW1P 1WG. Registered in England and Wales. Number 8860726.

IT Leadership // IT Strategy
09:06 AM
Connect Directly

Open-Source Vs. Commercial Software: A False Dilemma

There's a religious war between the defenders of open-source and commercial product supporters. Ultimately, the question is really one of requirements.

When the question of whether or not an organization should use open-source or commercial products arises, the discussion frequently seems to focus on extremes.

These positions are usually based upon a number of myths regarding both sides. There appear to be very specific stereotypes surrounding the types of consumers of open-source vs. commercial off-the-shelf (COTS) products. Open-source users are often viewed as strapped for cash, usually in the academic or non-profit realms, therefore willing to accept the risk involved with a product that isn't backed by a profit-driven company. Enterprise users are perceived as needing the stability and certainty that come in the form of a support contract with a commercial product.

But is this really the case or are the lines much blurrier regarding the seemingly large divide between open-source and commercial products?

There's a religious war that inevitably ensues between the defenders of open-source and commercial product supporters. The open-source guys are seen as being in it for love. They work harder to find solutions, unimpeded by the demands of commerce -- i.e., shareholders. COTS people proclaim their products are more dependable. After all, they've been rigorously tested prior to release and provide 24x7 support options for customers who can't afford service problems due to software bugs. But is this really the case?

At least in the security realm, problems don't discriminate between the commercial and open-source realms -- neither are exempt from embarrassing vulnerabilities. One only has to make a cursory examination of the latest US-CERT notifications to debunk that myth. There are plenty of commercial products that make appearances alongside open-source, even with their bug bounties and impressive security budgets. Profit-driven or not, humans write software and they're prone to error.

[For more insights on open source software, read Open Source's Deep-Seated Conflict.]

As for documentation, technical writing is a difficult skill that few on either side seem to master. Most in the industry would admit to documentation gaps in open-source as well as with commercial products. And when that product documentation can sometimes weigh a metric ton or be comparable in length to War and Peace, it really isn't very effective anyway.

Regarding customer support, just as commercial products offer tiered options, open-source products also have this capability. Sometimes it may be through a third-party, or more often a company may have commercial and community editions such as Rapid7 and One is licensed and sold with official support offerings, while the other uses crowd-sourced assistance via user groups.

What many professionals also often forget or fail to grasp is that open-source software usually forms the foundation of many commercial products. Take the offerings from the Internet Software Consortium (ISC): Almost every implementation of DNS is ultimately based upon their original BIND software, as well as DHCP. Would we even have some of the robust commercial solutions of today without the efforts of pioneers such as Paul Vixie and Eric Allman?

Ultimately, the question is really one of requirements. Which one will best meet the needs of the organization? Would it be better served with an open-source product that can be customized to meet a very specific use-case or is it more appropriate to give up the perfect for the good? How much time and resources can a business afford to spend on custom solutions, which often demands cultivating a savvy workforce who can deploy and manage it? However, do you need to blow your budget on commercial options for every problem? There are levels or subtlety involved in these decisions that can't be resolved by black-or-white thinking. The choice between open-source and COTS is usually a false dilemma with the reality being that they aren't mutually exclusive.

Could the growing movement toward open source hardware rewrite the rules for computer and networking hardware the way Linux, Apache, and Android have for software? Also in the Open Source Hardware issue of InformationWeek: Mark Hurd explains his "once-in-a-career opportunity" at Oracle.

Michele Chubirka, also known as Mrs. Y, is a recovering Unix engineer with a focus on network security. She likes long walks in hubsites, traveling to security conferences, and spending extended hours in the Bat Cave. She believes every problem can be solved with a "for" ... View Full Bio

We welcome your comments on this topic on our social media channels, or [contact us directly] with questions about the site.
Comment  | 
Print  | 
More Insights
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View
User Rank: Apprentice
6/24/2014 | 5:14:14 PM
Re: Comercial software
Ugh duhh commerical hands down.


Sure and an indie developer or consumer open source works well.

The minute you talk to a lawyer about the documentation you need to provide before you get slapped with a lawsuit for software utlizing a Monotype font, an Oracle API or some sort of derivaitve work that may or maybe not a rip have zero people to back you up..Time to get a lawyer. License fees are always cheaper then legal fees.


Great until you actually start making money on something; but on the worlds stage you are open to any claim and if you want to be big get ready to fend off those claims.


Essentially if you have a comapny lawyer or a any one that knows about IP alwyas go commerical.


That and most people who get together for fun to put a project together never put their blood sweat and tears into something that a corporation has QA's..provides support and covers your ass.


The difference is buying a cell phone from craigslist vs your local verzion store. You know what you get if it fails and you know it's not stolen.

User Rank: Apprentice
5/21/2014 | 1:43:46 AM
Comercial software
I think open sources software works better than the rest. I was very impressed by this post, this site has always been pleasant news Thank you very much for such an interesting post, and I meet them more often then I visited this site.
User Rank: Apprentice
5/18/2014 | 10:47:08 AM
Re: Philosophy rules the dilemma
OSS is great, but like any other software it needs managing and care.

Without this you will be investing lots of time and other resources.

That's why we developed our WhiteSource automated open source Inventory management, Inventory reports, Automated open source license compliance, Proactive alerts and License documentationֻ.
All are managed automatically and seamlessly integrate into your development servers
User Rank: Apprentice
5/18/2014 | 9:39:13 AM
Philosophy rules the dilemma
The question of exclusive and inclusiveness of these platforms doesn't necessarliy determine the useability  of one over another.  I think its matter of culture, philosophy and business need of any organization that literally determines the platform. More specifically, the operation costs of IS system and the size of company plays a key role in implementing the COTS or Open-source platform. Also, the  need of research and development, the availability of open-source enthusiasts, the availability of infrastructures and the business need are the key-factors. However, it is  non-deniable that for the majority of these issues, open-source easily supercede the proprietayr platform except in the support and operations. Nevertheless, if you have a good operation along with research and development-team, the open-source is unbeatable.



The Best Way to Get Started with Data Analytics
John Edwards, Technology Journalist & Author,  7/8/2020
10 Cyberattacks on the Rise During the Pandemic
Cynthia Harvey, Freelance Journalist, InformationWeek,  6/24/2020
IT Trade Shows Go Virtual: Your 2020 List of Events
Jessica Davis, Senior Editor, Enterprise Apps,  5/29/2020
White Papers
Register for InformationWeek Newsletters
Current Issue
Key to Cloud Success: The Right Management
This IT Trend highlights some of the steps IT teams can take to keep their cloud environments running in a safe, efficient manner.
Flash Poll