Movie Studios Lose In Case Against File-Sharing Apps - InformationWeek

InformationWeek is part of the Informa Tech Division of Informa PLC

This site is operated by a business or businesses owned by Informa PLC and all copyright resides with them.Informa PLC's registered office is 5 Howick Place, London SW1P 1WG. Registered in England and Wales. Number 8860726.


Movie Studios Lose In Case Against File-Sharing Apps

The decision is likely to force the industry to take the more costly and less-popular route of going directly after file-swappers.

SAN FRANCISCO (AP) -- In a judicial blow to the entertainment industry, a federal appeals court ruled that makers of two leading file-sharing programs aren't legally liable for the songs, movies, and other copyrighted works their users swap online.

The decision is likely to force the industry to take the more costly and less popular route of going directly after file-swappers.

Jack Valenti, president of the Motion Picture Association of America Inc., said his group is reviewing its next step following Thursday's ruling by the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in favor of Grokster Ltd. and StreamCast Networks Inc.

Mitch Bainwol, chairman of the Recording Industry Association of America, said the decision begs the question of whether "digital music will be enjoyed in a fashion that supports the creative process or one that robs it of its future."

Recording companies already have sued more than 3,400 such users; at least 600 of the cases were eventually settled for roughly $3,000 each.

Among other reasons, the three-judge panel unanimously upheld a lower court ruling that dismissed the bulk of the lawsuit brought by movie studios and music labels because Grokster and StreamCast don't have central servers pointing users to copyrighted material, as the original Napster did.

"In the context of this case, the software design is of great import," Judge Sidney R. Thomas wrote.

The panel noted that the software firms simply provide software that lets individual users share information over the Internet, regardless of whether that information was copyrighted.

"History has shown that time and market forces often provide equilibrium in balancing interests, whether the new technology be a player piano, a copier, a tape recorder, a video recorder, a personal computer, a karaoke machine, or an MP3 player," Thomas wrote. "Thus, it's prudent for courts to exercise caution before restructuring liability theories."

Civil libertarians also had warned that a defeat for Grokster and StreamCast could have forced technology companies such as Microsoft to delay or kill innovative products that give consumers more control.

The decision came nearly two weeks after attorneys general from 45 states sent letters to seven companies that offer online file-sharing software, including Grokster and StreamCast, hinting at possible legal consequences if the networks don't better inform computer users about potential copyright violations from sharing files.

The attorneys general asked the companies to improve how they inform those who use their software about potential legal and security risks associated with file sharing, which include being sued for copyright infringement, identity theft, and unwittingly being exposed to pornography, computer viruses, and spyware.

Napster was shut down after the 9th Circuit ruled that its centralized servers, which contained directories to thousands of copyrighted songs, made it legally liable for contributing to copyright infringement.

But in the wake of that ruling, peer-to-peer technology developed, avoiding the need for a central hub and arguably limiting the liability of the companies involved.

Fred von Lohmann, who represented Los Angeles-based StreamCast, said the ruling follows "the same principle that people who make crowbars aren't responsible for the robberies that may be committed with those crowbars."

Thursday's ruling could influence a separate ongoing entertainment industry case against Sharman Networks Ltd., makers of the Kazaa file-swapping program, which averages more users than any other file-sharing software.

A Sharman attorney, Rod Dorman, said the company now would seek to have a U.S. court declare Kazaa legal. But he noted Thursday's ruling wouldn't directly affect the recording industry's lawsuit against Sharman in Australian courts.

In a different case, the maker of iMesh file-sharing software recently agreed to pay $4.1 million to the recording industry for copyright infringement and to change its Internet service later this year to prevent consumers from illegally distributing music or downloading songs.

Thursday's ruling makes it less likely another company would settle.

The lower court ruling cited the U.S. Supreme Court's 1984 decision in the Sony Betamax case. The court said Sony wasn't liable when people used its Betamax videocassette recorder to copy movies illegally because the technology had significant uses that didn't violate copyrights.

The studios and labels argued that while Sony couldn't control how consumers used their VCRs, Grokster and StreamCast could filter the copyrighted content from their systems, like they do with computer viruses, but refuse to do so, because the free songs and movies are what draw their users and ultimately generate ad profits.

We welcome your comments on this topic on our social media channels, or [contact us directly] with questions about the site.
Comment  | 
Print  | 
More Insights
11 Things IT Professionals Wish They Knew Earlier in Their Careers
Lisa Morgan, Freelance Writer,  4/6/2021
Time to Shift Your Job Search Out of Neutral
Jessica Davis, Senior Editor, Enterprise Apps,  3/31/2021
Does Identity Hinder Hybrid-Cloud and Multi-Cloud Adoption?
Joao-Pierre S. Ruth, Senior Writer,  4/1/2021
White Papers
Register for InformationWeek Newsletters
The State of Cloud Computing - Fall 2020
The State of Cloud Computing - Fall 2020
Download this report to compare how cloud usage and spending patterns have changed in 2020, and how respondents think they'll evolve over the next two years.
Current Issue
Successful Strategies for Digital Transformation
Download this report to learn about the latest technologies and best practices or ensuring a successful transition from outdated business transformation tactics.
Flash Poll