Smuggled iPhones Not Hot In China - InformationWeek

InformationWeek is part of the Informa Tech Division of Informa PLC

This site is operated by a business or businesses owned by Informa PLC and all copyright resides with them.Informa PLC's registered office is 5 Howick Place, London SW1P 1WG. Registered in England and Wales. Number 8860726.

IoT
IoT
Mobile // Mobile Business
News
9/29/2014
11:20 AM
50%
50%

Smuggled iPhones Not Hot In China

Demand for iPhone 6 and 6 Plus devices smuggled into China slows dramatically, even as Apple prepares to start selling the devices there.

6 Things Not To Do With iPhone 6
6 Things Not To Do With iPhone 6
(Click image for larger view and slideshow.)

The Apple iPhone 6 has yet to go on sale officially in China, but that's not stopping smugglers from selling the phones on city streets and in back alleys. Black market sellers looking to make a quick buck, however, may have already exhausted early demand for the device -- which doesn't bode well for Apple.

"The gray market for the new iPhones has already dried up," reports The New York Times. The NYT estimates tens of thousands of iPhone 6 and 6 Plus handsets have been smuggled into China from Australia, Hong Kong, Singapore, and New York City. The black market is essentially flooded. One reseller has been forced to slash street prices from $1,960-$2,450 down to $1,060-$1,436. The iPhones netted wholesalers about $163 per handset, but with so many phones available and demand way down, black market operators may instead lose money on their iPhone stock.

How did the phones get there?

When the iPhone 6 and 6 Plus went on sale in the US on September 19, videographer Casey Neistat cased some of the lines at Apple stores in Manhattan and found a large number of Chinese customers waiting to buy the new devices. He asked them what they intended to do with their new phones, and many suggested the new phones were for themselves or for loved ones.

Neistat didn't believe them. He produced a six-minute video titled "Black Market Takes Over the iPhone 6 Lines" that has earned 2.8 million views so far. The video suggests that most of the Chinese buyers waiting in line to buy iPhones on launch day were there to make some cash by reselling the phones, and that many were there as a result of organized smuggling rings run by the Chinese mafia. (For the record, I'd estimate 90% of the people waiting in line to buy the iPhone 6 and 6 Plus on September 19 where I purchased mine in New Jersey were also Chinese.)

[iPhone 6: Dali Edition? Read Apple iPhone 6 Bendgate: Top 10 Tweets.]

Analysts disagree with Neistat's base assumption that a large criminal organization led to the lines witnessed in big cities on September 19. Linda Sui, an analyst at Strategy Analytics, told TIME, "They need money. Most of them are low-income people." In her view, many Chinese iPhone buyers were there to grab a device and turn it around to someone else who intended to ship it to China and resell it there. "In Chinatown there are small circles, so many people know each other," said Sui.

In the US, new iPhones couldn't be resold for more than about $1,000, leaving the original purchaser with a profit of $300 to $400 per device. The buyer then arranged for the phones to make their way to mainland China. Most of the devices entered via Hong Kong, according to the NYT, and were then sent via internal routes to large cities throughout the country.

When the iPhone 5s went on sale last year, it launched in China the same day it launched in other cities around the world. That put a damper on iPhone smugglers. This year, the iPhone's launch in China has been delayed as Apple has secured only one of two needed licenses to sell the device there. The company expects to secure the second license in time to commence sales this week, giving smugglers precious little time to recoup their investment before the phone can be purchased in stores. The slackened demand, however, is troubling.

iPhones were the hot phone to have in China several years ago, but in-country hardware makers have changed that story. Phone manufacturers such as Huawei, Xiaomi, and Meizu have stepped in with competitive handsets that cost far less. Though Apple sells tens of millions of iPhones in China, sales of Android-based phones from Chinese competitors number in the hundreds of millions. It doesn't help that the Chinese government has decreed US-made products undesirable.

Apple hasn't yet said when the iPhone 6 and iPhone 6 Plus will launch in China, but analysts will be watching closely to see just how well Apple does in the world's largest market for mobile phones.

If you just look at vendor financials, the enterprise storage business seems stuck in neutral. However, flat revenue numbers mask a scorching pace of technical innovation, ongoing double-digit capacity growth in enterprises, and dramatic changes in how and where businesses store data. Get the 2014 State of Storage report today. (Free registration required.)

Eric is a freelance writer for InformationWeek specializing in mobile technologies. View Full Bio

We welcome your comments on this topic on our social media channels, or [contact us directly] with questions about the site.
Comment  | 
Print  | 
More Insights
Comments
Oldest First  |  Newest First  |  Threaded View
Page 1 / 4   >   >>
Lorna Garey
50%
50%
Lorna Garey,
User Rank: Author
9/29/2014 | 11:39:38 AM
Status
It all comes down to a status symbol -- what is that little logo worth? And to people who value such things, presumably being one of the first to have the phone, before the unwashed masses, is key. So yeah, seems like Apple should be worried.
Whoopty
50%
50%
Whoopty,
User Rank: Ninja
9/29/2014 | 12:45:17 PM
Grey markets, grey area
I was burned by grey market products once. After having picked up a stack of hard drives from a well known online retailer, a few of them failed and I found that neither my retailer warranty - which had as you might have expected, only just gone out of date - nor my manufacturer warranty were valid. The latter wasn't claimable since the product had been sold outside of its intended region, something I had no concept of at the time and wasn't aware of at the point of purchase.  

That particular company has cleaned up its act these days, but it's certainly something to watch out for and consider, especially if you know you're buying a product that's been shipped around. 
mmil105
50%
50%
mmil105,
User Rank: Apprentice
9/29/2014 | 12:48:46 PM
Did anyone do some basic fact checking?
The article says 'It doesn't help that the Chinese government has decreed US-made products undesirable.'

There's no such thing as a US-made smartphone!  Motorola briefly tried it when it was owned by Google, but EVERY iPhone sold in both the US and China is made in China!

Furthermore, I witnessed the lines of Chinese buyers in Manhattan firsthand and while they definitely don't look to be associated with any organized crime syndicates, the buyers are NOT actually smuggling anything into China either.  I witnessed (and the Neistat video clearly shows) the buyers handing off the phones as soon as they leave the store.

The main reason iPhone demand has dropped is because of the recent government crackdown in China on corruption.  Conspicious consumption (displaying expensive phones, watches, cars, etc.) is considered an important marker of status in China but now it is also considered to be grounds for investigation if someone is one of the tens of millions of government employees in the country.

An article in a tech magazine should have some very basic fact checking done before it's published.
Henrisha
50%
50%
Henrisha,
User Rank: Strategist
9/29/2014 | 12:51:45 PM
Re: Status
Now that you bring it up... Recently I have come across ads for iPhone 6 "1 to 1 replica", which are obviously knock-offs, at about a quarter of the actual phone's price. If you see it as a status symbol, you wouldn't be quick to jump at this "bargain"-- unless you'll be showing it off only in pictures, because clearly it won't work or even look like an actual iPhone in person.
TerryB
50%
50%
TerryB,
User Rank: Ninja
9/29/2014 | 1:17:00 PM
Re: Did anyone do some basic fact checking?
Instead of ragging on IW for "fact checking", check your comment for common sense. Who cares where it is manufactured, any legit sale of Apple product gives profit to Apple and thus US taxes. That is China's intent, they are being dinks because US has cracked down on them for dumping and quality/safety issues on their products. China doesn't care where they are made.

Nothing in your comment contradicts what Eric said. It's good point you make about corruption crackdown but who really knows the effect of that on black market items over there. Those long lines make a lot more sense now.
mejiac
50%
50%
mejiac,
User Rank: Ninja
9/29/2014 | 1:24:22 PM
Re: Status
@Loma,

This same trend can be seen in other third world countries, where phones aren't restricted to the carrier, and even more so, the local service provide actually encourage the black market because they're willing to activate any phone as long as they can support it.

For both Iphone and Samsung, and like any product that it's trending, black market smuggling will always exist.

 
mejiac
50%
50%
mejiac,
User Rank: Ninja
9/29/2014 | 1:28:13 PM
Laws of Offer and Demand
Erick,

First, great article!,

Like any given product, if it's somethign that's trending and also part of a fashion statement, it'll have a black market behind it.

This is obvious in many fashion clothing articles, so smartphones aren't shielded from it.

Same goes for Laptops and tablets... if it's something that consumers want desperatly, then a profit can be made of it.

Like you mentioned, I was monitoring ebay sales out of curiority, and was amazed at the prices people were paying for the Iphone 6 (versus simply being patient and wait for supplies to re-stock).

But here's a question: do companies like Apple and Samsung tend to fight it? or simply accept it as a byproduct of the popularity and demand they're seing with there flagship products?

What does the community think?
mmil105
50%
50%
mmil105,
User Rank: Apprentice
9/29/2014 | 2:05:25 PM
Re: Did anyone do some basic fact checking?
Did you actually read the article?  

It clearly says 'US-made products' NOT made by a company 'that gives profit to Apple and thus US taxes.'  If you believe that the article says China didn't care where the phone was made, why would the article say 'US-made products'?

I always check facts before I write something.  Many people, both here and in China, incorrectly believe that the iPhone is a US-made product precisely because of articles like this.

You also seem to agree about my analysis about corruption - just do a Google search for 'iPhone 6 China corruption.'  However, corruption is not even mentioned in the article, yet it is listed as the predominant cause by many legitimate sources.  The fact the iPhone 6 is yet another Chinese-made smartphone (though it is designed by a non-Chinese company) is a secondary cause at best.

All I am saying is that I expected some better fact-checking from a Tech publication.  
TerryB
50%
50%
TerryB,
User Rank: Ninja
9/29/2014 | 2:22:20 PM
Re: Did anyone do some basic fact checking?
You are opening a can of worms worrying about Mfg origins. Under your logic, Toyota would be a US product because we have plenty of manufacturing facilities here making Toyota's for US buyers. But none of profits stay in US.

Apple is a US based company, that is what China is targeting. And I'm guessing they wrote iOS in California. But everyone knows there is very little electronics made in US anymore. China's intent is to prevent US companies from gaining sales in their country, regardless of their mfg structure. Surely you understand that?

Because China is source of so many rare minerals, good luck finding anything electronic which doesn't have something from China in it, even if everything else done here.
CunC132
50%
50%
CunC132,
User Rank: Apprentice
9/29/2014 | 2:32:56 PM
Re: Did anyone do some basic fact checking?
Last time I checked "Assemble" does not have the same meaning as "make". I bought a damn iKea table which individual parts supplied and started assembling process to end up with a functional table. Did I "make" that table? fck no. I assembled it. Same case here.
Page 1 / 4   >   >>
Slideshows
10 Top Cloud Computing Startups
Cynthia Harvey, Freelance Journalist, InformationWeek,  8/3/2020
Commentary
How Enterprises Can Adopt Video Game Cloud Strategy
Joao-Pierre S. Ruth, Senior Writer,  7/28/2020
Commentary
Conversational AI Comes of Age
Guest Commentary, Guest Commentary,  8/7/2020
White Papers
Register for InformationWeek Newsletters
Video
Current Issue
Special Report: Why Performance Testing is Crucial Today
This special report will help enterprises determine what they should expect from performance testing solutions and how to put them to work most efficiently. Get it today!
Slideshows
Flash Poll