Re: Another review complaining it's not an iPhone
"I have been using my Lumia 925 dark-coloured steel phone for 2 years now." Does a 2-year-old model still count as a flagship for those looking for a Windows Phone today? Taken in context (rather than filtered through indignation), there is nothing factually inaccurate about what I wrote.
"personally I have all the apps I need (about 40) and have never paid for one in my life ... Ooh, only 300,000 to choose from, how will I manage?" Great! For you, then, apps are a non-issue. But your perspective seems to imply that just because you don't care about this point, others won't care. I can appreciate that as a Windows Phone fan, you might be tired of hearing people complain about app selection, which has been an ongoing criticism. But even if you're sick of hearing about it, the app issue is still a valid criticism.
"Most iPhone users haven't tried WP handsets - living with them, not just for 2 weeks - but still criticize them because of iPhone reviewers basically complaining that it's not an iPhone." I've used this particular phone for two weeks, but I used the HTC 8x exclusively for six months after the iPhone I had at the time got dropped in water. I mentioned in the article that I had previous Windows Phone experience, though I didn't belabor the point. In any event, I included the note about the iPhone to be transparent about how my experiences might have shaped my perspective. Evidently it's better for reviewers to feign complete objectivity, rather than admitting that their perspective is shaped by experience and perspective?
"The bit about the feeling comfortable - very subjective - if you're used to one size any other will feel too large/small." The article is listed as commentary and described in the headline as a "hands on" review-- isn't it obvious that aspects of this are subjective? Moreover, the article said that unfamiliarity with the new size was a certainly a factor.
But, hey, you seem to live in a world in which people are either iOS-loving sheep, or free thinkers who shun Apple. I tend to think we live in a slightly more complicated world in which there's room for more than one device to be appealing, and in which it isn't anathema for a single reporter to subjectively explain why he prefers one type of one to another, while still praising aspects of both phones.